Most families enjoy the delights of having an ice cream on a hot summers day but there are always arguments about which flavor to buy. What about making your own frozen desserts that allow you to add your own flavors and toppings? Well, you can if you buy a home ice cream maker.
These are actually really simple devices that don’t require any expertise.
The only problem is that there are so many different models on the market it is tricky to know which one to buy. There are also thousands of ice cream maker reviews online so it takes hours to trawl through them all.
Just keep reading this article and you will gain enough knowledge to be able to purchase one of the top ten featured models we have been able to find. If you like a certain model then just follow the link to the Amazon website and have your machine ready for some treats in a just a day or two.
Our Top 10 Best Ice Cream Maker Recommendations
| #1 - Lello 4080 Musso Lussino: Top Of The Range Features || Top Of The Range Features||5.0 stars out of 5|
| #2 - Breville BCI600XL: Very Customizable Settings || Very Customizable Settings||4.5 stars out of 5|
| #3 - Whynter ICM-15LS Ice Cream Maker: Great Built-In Timer || Great Built-In Timer||4.0 stars out of 5|
Table of Contents
- Our Top 10 Best Ice Cream Maker Recommendations
- 1. Lello 4080 Musso Lussino: Top Of The Range Features
- 2. Breville BCI600XL: Very Customizable Settings
- 3. Whynter ICM-15LS Ice Cream Maker: Great Built-In Timer
- 4. Cuisinart ICE-70: Excellent Value For Money
- 5. Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE: The Cheapest Option
- 6. Cuisinart ICE-45: The Easiest To Use
- 7. Cuisinart ICE-30R: For An Old Fashioned Look
- 8. Nostalgia ICMP400WD: Cool Vintage Look
- 9. Cuisinart ICE-100: Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker
- 10. Hamilton Beach: Cheap But Limited Results
- What Features You Need To Focus On
- Automatic or manual
- Program Settings
This Lello 4080 Musso Lussino model is arguably the best product featured in this article. Made in Italy this model is very expensive but constantly delivers the goods up to a professional industrial standard. So, if you feel like being pampered then this is the model for you.
With this machine, you don’t have to know much about ice cream making because it is fully automatic. You simply put the ingredients into the bowl, press two buttons and wait for 30-minutes to see fantastic results.
You can also make sorbet, frozen yoghurt, gelato and frozen drinks in this machine so it is not just an ice cream make maker but a dessert maker. The 1.5-quart capacity bowl freezes 3-quarts of sorbet or ice cream per hour. You don’t have to worry about anything thanks to this machine having different timer control settings for different frozen desserts.
With this model, you don’t need to store the bowl in the refrigerator to freeze. This means that you can carry on making another batch. If your ice cream becomes too hard then the machine with automatically shut itself off.
As you would expect with something that is Italian-made this 100-watt machine is very stylish. The main body is made of stainless steel as is the bowl and paddle. This also means it easier to clean. When you buy this product it also comes with a 1-year warranty and an instruction booklet with many recipes.
- Simple to use as its fully automatic.
- Comes with a 1-year warranty,
- Includes an instruction booklet with many recipes.
- If your ice cream becomes too hard the unit will automatically shut itself off.
- All made from stylish stainless steel which is also easy to clean.
- Very expensive product.
This Breville BCI600XL model is fairly expensively priced but it does deliver good ice cream making results. With this model, you have the choice between setting it fully automatic or manual function which means you get to decide how much effort you put into making your ice cream.
The Breville BCI600XL comes with 12-hardness automatic settings so that you can make different types of frozen desserts. You can make frozen yoghurt, gelato and sorbet. There is a pre-cool setting so that you are able to get the right operating temperature for the dessert you are making.
This product has a bowl capacity of 1.5-quart and has a keep cool setting for up to 3-hours. It also has a self-refrigerating compressor and runs on 165-watts. If you are looking for an ice cream maker for kids then this easy to use model is made of BPA free materials and also features a child lock to make sure that your kids don’t harm themselves.
When your desserts are ready to serve, this machine will make a beeping sound or one of three musical tunes.
People who decided to purchase this product were really disappointed that it did come with any recipes included. This is a shame given the fairly expensive price.
- Comes with 12-hardness automatic settings so that you can make different types of frozen desserts.
- Comes with the choice of setting it fully automatic or manual function.
- Has a child lock feature.
- Has a self-refrigerating compressor.
- Pre-cooling and keep cool settings.
- No recipes included with this product.
- Fairly expensive product.
The Whynter ICM-15LS model is a bit on the expensive side but it is a high-performing commercial frozen dessert maker. With this machine, you get the benefit of it having a powerful built-in cooling compressor. This means that you can carry on making frozen desserts without the hassle of having to pre-freeze in the refrigerator.
Made of stylish stainless steel, this machine will make a wide range of frozen delights in roughly 30-40-minutes.
Easy to use, this unit has a removable bowl and BPA-free churn blade which means it is simple to store and easy to clean. It also benefits from having a large 1.6-quart capacity and a built-in electric audible timer system.
The motor in this machine is designed to automatically shut itself off if the mixture gets too hard. This helps to prevent any damage to your device when using in your home. The device runs on 150-watts of power.
This model also has an LCD timer and temperature display system. The cooling temperature of this device ranges from -0.4F to -31F. If you decide to buy this product then you will also receive a scooper for your desserts as well as some secret recipes.
- Has a large 1.6-quart capacity.
- Comes with a dessert scooper.
- Comes with secret recipes.
- Has an LCD timer and temperature display system.
- This machine is designed to automatically shut itself off if the mixture gets too hard.
- Some people find the compressor to be too weak.
- Fairly expensive price.
This excellent value for money Cuisinart ICE-70 model is able to produce 2-quarts of sorbet, gelato, frozen yoghurt and of course ice cream. Making homemade desserts with this model is pretty easy thanks to having a simple one-button system. Due to having a good paddle the processing time of your desserts is just 20-minutes.
Even if you don’t know how to make ice cream with an ice cream maker then don’t worry as this machine also has a simple control panel with LCD display screen as well as having three different speed settings.
Also on the display screen is the countdown timer which automatically shuts itself off when your dessert is ready. Stylish to look at thanks to being made of brushed chrome, this machine is BPA-free and easy to clean. It also has the advantage of having an ingredient spout with an integrated measuring cup.
When you buy this product it also comes with a recipe book and instruction book as well as a 3-year warranty included.
- Has three different speed settings.
- Comes with a recipe book and instruction book.
- Comes with a 3-year warranty.
- Has an ingredient spout with an integrated measuring cup.
- Has an LCD display screen and a countdown timer that auto-switches off.
- The lid can be a bit too flimsy.
This Nostalgia model can be considered the best option featured in this article in terms of being the cheapest in price. If you are a fan of the old-fashioned look then this is the model for you. It comes with an easy-to-clean plastic bucket and see-through lids for easy viewing and freezer storage.
In addition to this, it also has a powerful electric motor that does all the churning for you automatically. That saves you from doing any of the churnings manually. The motor also locks into place to ensure that all the parts are totally secure during operation. It comes with a convenient handle for effortless carrying.
This unit is capable of making up to 4-quarts of frozen desserts in one go which is plenty to keep the family happy.
Using this device is fairly easy you simply add your ingredients in the aluminum canister and place in the middle of the bucket. You then layer it with ice and salt and set it to go. When you purchase this product, you do so knowing that it is totally BPA-free and comes with a user manual which includes recipes.
- Easy to clean and total BPA-free.
- Has a powerful motor that automatically does all the churning.
- Excellent price.
- Motor locking system.
- Stylish old-fashioned look.
- Some people have reported that the paddle does not spin.
This nifty Cuisinart ICE-45 model is a bit on the pricey side but it is very simple to use due to it being fully automatic. Using this machine requires hardly any effort at all. You simply just add the ingredients set it to go and wait for just 20-minutes for the tasty end results. There is also a mixture gauge so that you know the right amount of mixture to use.
This model comes with a mixing arm which mixes the ingredients in a freezing bowl to create smooth soft ice cream. There is also a dispensing bracket with handle. You just pull down the handle and the dessert will go into your cone or bowl.
It also comes with 1.5-quart freezer bowl which means you don’t have to use a refrigerator to freeze before eating. There is also and lockable removable lid with window. The window enables you to pour ingredients through the top and watch it freeze. This machine also has a powerful heavy-duty motor as well as having a convenient condiment chute.
The benefit of having the condiment chute is that you can add topping mixes to your ice. They go through the chute straight onto the cone or into the bowl. There are three condiment holders. You just have to pull the lever to pick the one that you want to add to your dessert.
- Has a powerful motor
- Very easy to use.
- Also, very easy to clean.
- Has a condiment chute as well has three condiment holders.
- Also has a lockable removable lid with window.
- People say it is overpriced for how it performs.
This Cuisinart ICE-30R unit has an old-fashioned vintage look and is available to buy for a fairly reasonable price. Due to this machine being fully automatic you can be enjoying frozen desserts or drinks in just 25-minutes. You do not have to spend loads of time playing chef in the kitchen.
The motor, automatic paddle and double-insulated freezing bowl do all the hard work so that you don’t have to. After just 25-minutes the results are smooth throughout and of course very tasty.
This model has a brushed metal style that gives the unit a vintage twist on a modern product. The freezing bowl is able to hold a maximum of 2-quarts of frozen dessert. It also has the added advantage of being designed with a large ingredient spout so that you can easily add in any mix-ins you may desire.
One of the downsides people have found with this product is that it is very noisy when in operation. If you can withstand the noise then this may still be the model for you. This product is easy to clean and also come with a 3-year limited warranty included in the purchase price.
- Fully automatic and easy to use.
- Easy to clean.
- Fairly reasonable price.
- Comes with a limited 3-year warranty.
- Designed with a large ingredient spout so that you can easily add in any mix-ins you may desire.
- Some people have reported that this model is very noisy.
This excellently priced Nostalgia ICMP400WD model has a real wood finish to give it that true vintage look. The overall look brings to mind the old-fashioned hand-crank ice cream makers but it also has loads of up to date modern features.
As well as looking the part this device comes with a powerful electric motor that is able to deal with all that churning for you. So, this means no tough manual effort on your part. This product is designed with a motor locking system which helps to secure all the parts in place. It also has a see-through lid which allows you to view the freezing process.
It is very easy to use this unit you just add your ingredients as well as salt and ice and let the powerful motor do all the hard work. You are able to produce up to 4-quarts of tasty desserts in the aluminum canister. You can also add toppings of your own choice. All elements are BPA-free and easy to clean.
When you have finished making your dessert you can use the lid and cap to store any leftovers in the freezer. It also comes with a manual which includes recipes.
- Old-fashioned vintage look.
- Comes with recipes.
- Comes with recipes.
- You can produce up to 4-quarts of tasty desserts in the aluminum canister.
- Has a motor locking system.
- Some people have reported that the product can be hard to use.
This Cuisinart ICE-100 model is certainly not the best ice cream maker featured in this article mainly due to performance and price. While this model is not the most expensive on the market is also a far way from being the cheapest too. Added to this, people who have purchased this model also report that they would have expected a better performance given the price.
However, this machine is fully automatic and benefits from having a commercial quality compressor that helps to produce gelato and ice cream in a 1.5-quart capacity bowl. The bowl is made of aluminum and there is no need to pre-chill the bowl before use. It also has the advantage of having a lift-out handle to make life easier.
This model comes with an ice cream paddle as well as a gelato paddle so that you can make the dessert of your choice. There is a 10-minute keep cool feature to ensure that your dessert keeps cool after it has been made.
You can keep a close eye on how your dessert is coming along by watching the blue LCD display with a 60-minute countdown timer. The touchpad controls are easy to use. Adding your own topping ingredients is easy just remove the see-through lid during the mixing process.
This product is easy to use thanks to the simple start/stop button that can be activated at any time during the process. It can be paused and restarted again easily. If you buy this product you will also receive an instruction book and some recipes.
- Easy to use.
- Has a 10-minute cooling feature.
- Comes with a blue LCD display and a 60-minute countdown timer.
- Fully automatic.
- Comes with an aluminum 1.5-quart capacity bowl that has a lift-out handle.
- Expensive for how it performs.
This small compact Hamilton Beach model is cheap in price but unfortunately also feels cheaply made. The excellent price will attract many buyers to this product but many people who have bought it have been left disappointed by its overall performance.
It feels cheaply constructed, produces limited results and is also very noisy when in use. Another disadvantage is that you have to pre-freeze the bowl before making any desserts which adds time to the overall process.
Now for the plus points. The Hamilton Beach has a 1.5-quart capacity bowl which allows you make a whole range of different desserts in as little as 20-minutes. You can add your own mixings or toppings without too much fuss to allow you do have the dessert of your choice.
This machine is fairly easy to use with a simple on/off switch and you also get recipes included when you buy this product. Overall this model may be cheap in price but does not offer the quality of results that other models offer.
- Excellent price.
- Comes with recipes.
- Fairly easy to use.
- Has a 1.5-quart capacity bowl.
- Feels very cheaply made.
- Does not freeze as well as you would expect.
- Very noisy when in use.
What Features You Need To Focus On
Like with most kitchen cooking products the capacity is important depending on how many people you are planning to serve. In terms of the products featured in this article, you need to focus on the capacity of the freezing bowl.
The higher the capacity the more dessert you will be able to serve. For example, the units are measured in quarts, so if you have a large family you need to purchase a model that has the 2-quart capacity or above. Many of the products featured in this article are around 1.5-quart capacity.
A machine with a built-in compressor will often be more expensive to buy but it will save you a heap of time. There are models featured in this article that come with a built-in compressor. Basically, the compressor brings the ingredients you use to below freezing point because it has a chilling element.
This allows you to get on with creating your desserts without needing pre-freeze your bowl before starting. The models with chilling compressors often produce the best end results.
Automatic or manual
Most of the machines in this article have an automatic function which allows you to simply put in the ingredients and switch on the machine and let it work its magic.
Obviously, these models are more popular due to their ease of use but they are often a fair bit more expensive than a manual model. You can also buy a model that gives you the choice of using an automatic function or a manual function.
On some models, you will get different speed settings as well as a built-in timer and LCD display screen. Another feature is that it will automatically switch itself off if the mixture becomes too hard.
This means that you will always be eating tasty desserts and it also safeguards your machine from any damage over freezing may cause.
It goes without saying that with any food making product you are looking to buy it is important to consider how often you are going to use it and how many people will you be serving. If you are just going to be using the product to serve one or two people then it may be better to buy a small ice cream maker rather than a large capacity one.
The beauty of the products featured in this article is that you don’t really need to know how to make ice cream with it. Nearly all of the products are simple to use and come with easy to understand instructions.
So, what are you waiting for? Buy the model that best suits your requirements and start enjoying some delightful desserts.